A newly hired employee just showed me a Permanent Resident Card that says "Signature Waived" under the picture. Is this an acceptable I-9 document?

It is now, yes.  The Department of Homeland Security’s immigration division (USCIS) recently announced a change to the list of documents that would be acceptable for completing Section 2 of the Form I-9.  The change originated in a change to the way in which USCIS issues some Permanent Resident cards.  Specifically, in February of 2015 USCIS began issuing cards with a “Signature Waived” stamp below the picture.  The practice has been confirmed and these cards are acceptable List A documents, as they convey both work authority and the employee’s identity.

Here is a picture of the card, provided by USCIS for training purposes.  As an aside - note the name of the person is “Yellow Tulip.” Seemingly even ominous government agencies can show signs of levity.

Thompson Coe’s Tips of the Week are not intended as a solicitation, do not constitute legal advice and do not establish an attorney-client relationship.